Home > Blurb, Photo Books > Quality review of a Blurb Photobook.

Quality review of a Blurb Photobook.

February 16th, 2007 Leave a comment Go to comments

A few months back I posted how easy it is to create a photo book using the Blurb Booksmart software.

I ordered a few copies of this book from Blurb for myself and for relatives, and wanted to show you what the delivered book looks like so you can get a sense of the quality of the book.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

The books arrived packaged in a cardboard box that and each book is individually shrink wrapped. This is a nice touch so that your fingerprints don’t get all over the cover before you give the gift.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

This book was pretty thick at nearly 200 pages. As we saw in the pricing showdown for a variety of photobook makers, a book of this size is very reasonably priced with Blurb.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

Blurb Hardcovers come with a full color, full bleed dust cover. There are many different layouts, I happened to like the full bleed. You can have full page images on the front and back cover as well as on the inside flaps. This I tried to capture the gloss on the dustcover by showing you the reflectivity of the lights.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

The Hardcover is cased with linen, and the pages appear glued into the binding. I can’t find any evidence of stitching on the pages or binding.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

As of this writing, blurb does not imprint anything on the linen or spine.

The inside cover of the book is white; you’ll note that there is linen near the spine, which is finished with a glued white sheet of heavy paper on the actual cover. I have been satisfied so far with the quality and durability of the spine. We’ll see what happens in 50 years to see if the adhesive on the spine holds.

Blurb Booksmart photo book review
Inside, the photos are printed on heavy, glossy paper. The pages feel thicker and glossier than in most books, but certainly not as heavy as actual photo paper. The page weight is consistent with other art / coffee table books I own.

Held at a distance of 12 inches, there are no discernible “dots” in the printing. As you peer in closely you can make out the pattern of the dots that create the image. In comparison to magazine quality, or dust-jackets of “real-bookstore-books” the quality is on par, if only the tiniest bit more coarse. I’ve tried to create an enlargement here so you can see the pattern. This enlargement is a box roughly 5 millimeters on a side in the actual book. Note that the fine detail is preserved.

Blurb Booksmart photobook review

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

Blurb Booksmart photo book review

I learned from the Cool Tools website that Blurb uses the HP Indigo 50000, which according to HP achieves a quality of “812×1624 dpi when printing in high resolution mode” Citation.

Overall, I find the quality of the Blurb product quite impressive, and that is why I am a repeat customer. You can feel comfortable that you’ll get a quality product that showcases your photos.

That said, I agree with the assessment on Cool Tools. In short, bad photos will look bad in higher resolution. Blurry photos, out of focus images, scans of ink-jet-printer prints, scans of old 110 prints, overly-compressed jpgs, all will show less detail than a sharp-direct from digital images. Bear this in mind when you create your book. I have been supremely happy with the images from my 4.0 and 6.1 mega pixel cameras that appear in my Blurb BooksDon’t blame blurb if your source images can’t hold up to such high resolution printing.

[tags] photobook, blurb, booksmart, photo book[/tags]

Categories: Blurb, Photo Books Tags:
  1. Carl
    May 28th, 2009 at 20:51 | #1

    300 dpi = standard color magazine today
    (gossip magazine, celebrity, etc) :(

    it’s not PHOTO quality book.
    it need to be at least 1200 DPI.
    also the paper so thin, like those at magazines :(

  2. Carl
    May 28th, 2009 at 20:56 | #2

    maximum 300 DPI is said by Blurb itself
    at the faq section.

    I am really dissappointed :(

  3. Kent
    May 28th, 2009 at 22:12 | #3

    http://sharedink.com

    are so much better,
    it’s for Photo Book rather than just a Book.
    using online software.
    it’s so expensive :(

    I suggest u to red this as well.
    it’s an old post.

    http://www.daepublishing.com/pod/PODExposed.html

  4. May 29th, 2009 at 13:19 | #4

    Mike,

    I’d invite you to try our service as a comparison – we need a PDF file, you can create it as you like. Pop us an email, and we’ll work out a free book or massive discount or something .

    Edition One

  5. Steven
    May 30th, 2009 at 05:44 | #5

    Blurb Booksmart have limitations, it could generate the PDF document. But, it’s too Low Quality PDF file and have Watermark on every page. Make it useless for distributing.

  6. Steven
    May 30th, 2009 at 05:59 | #6

    Blurb is same as Lulu and other printed on demand companies which is limit the quality at maximum 300 DPI. It’s far beyond High Definition Image (very high quality photo) which has over 1200 DPI, some even reach 9600 DPI. Blurb is a book, NOT a PHOTO BOOK.

  7. Steven
    May 31st, 2009 at 01:44 | #7

    to achieve the maximum quality of the pictures printed by Blurb, you may need this guide:

    http://www.impulseadventure.com/photo/megapixels.html

  8. Steven
    June 3rd, 2009 at 01:23 | #8

    the paper not really thin. it just ok for me :) .
    But it so thin if compared to Sharedink.com paper.

  9. Steven
    June 3rd, 2009 at 01:27 | #9

    Sharedink paper is thick and much better
    for archival :) for your grandsons / granddaughters :D

    300 DPI – for critical eyes, you can see clearly the tiny grains if you look closely, zoom in the paper with your naked eyes.

  10. Stephanie
    June 4th, 2009 at 07:52 | #10

    Blurb is getting better, I just received my first book with premium paper. The paper is quite thick (not so thick).

    Also now, they print their barcode in form of a sticker instead on the cover directly, so you can peel off the sticker :)

    If I close up, I can see the tiny grains. You know it’s 300 DPI maximum.

    To be honest, he price is still too expensive for me.

    When designing with booksmart, make sure each picture do not less than the required optimum size shown on each picture frame, otherwise resize it to be smaller – to match the optimum size shown on the frame at least.

  11. Anna
    June 4th, 2009 at 19:26 | #11

    watch out, Blurb cut / trim the edge at 1/4 inch.
    when designing the front and back cover, watch out the black line, so you image safely printed.

  12. Original Sin
    June 11th, 2009 at 12:49 | #12

    2 years on, and your review still lives!

    Thanks for the pictures.

  13. BlackThumbEDQ
    June 20th, 2009 at 19:08 | #13

    Thanks for the review – we just saw someone’s Blurb book today and were very impressed with the quality.

    We’re considering doing something other than a picture book per se – my mom’s genealogy research which would include old scanned photos and documents (or some digital photos of her old photos and documents.)

    Any thoughts? We’re not looking for something to sell – just to make her happy and to donate to her genealogy library, so her family is represented.

  14. AnoloCany
    June 23rd, 2009 at 07:23 | #14

    blue chip casino reno casino guide ursula andress casino royale .laughlin casino reviews paradice casino east peoria illinois fallsview casino niagara falls starlight casino sports bar .payout poker and casino download casino free .sonic casino vegas casino shows ursula andress in casino royale ny casino las vegas .above tampa casino blackjack .Cool stuff – .follow .with compare foxwoods casino and resort ct us casino online Usualy The best val thorens casino also usa online casino no deposit bonus new orleans riverboat casino Why hotels near mystic lake casino The Usualy Is the chip in casino monterey bay casino las vegas Usualy For mohegan sun casino at pocono often hotels south lake tahoe casino m casino las vegas dover casino whether or no online golden casino mafia casino mafia wars ripping casino royale rushmore casino coupon All about making of casino royale And
    stanley vip casino star city casino dealer .Get and again cache creek casino and hotel Realy nice songs in the movie casino image as ak-chin casino .you are entering into a .and this is the best resource on .that was or again technical casino services ltd volcanic gold flash casino image as The best hull city casino above hollywood casino hard rock fiesta hotel and casino in henderson nevada royale casino most of the studio work for casino royale was filmed in what city As to majestic star casino indiana poker outside And .

  15. Pablo
    July 9th, 2009 at 17:05 | #15

    Excelent! I wanna one!

  16. July 26th, 2009 at 09:33 | #16

    Hi. You convinced me to switch from mypublisher to blurb! Only problem. my layouts are all in powerpoint and I normally save each slide as a JPEG. Now with Office 2007, I can save my slides as PDF, JPEG, PNG, etc etc, so my question is, how do I save them and what slide size should I save them in. I usually mutiply the page size by three to be safe but I have no idea if that will work with blurb. for instance, if my book is 10 by 8, i will save my slides as 30 by 24. It worked in mypublisher but will it work here? Help! and Thanks for your candid review above!

  17. Caroline
    July 31st, 2009 at 06:27 | #17

    I ordered 50 books from BLURB for an event. Did not have time to print the one book, unfortunately, but after making numerous books on MyPublisher.com I decided to try Blurb because I saved $5 per book. BIG MISTAKE. The quality of the photos is dark, they trimmed 1/4 inch off the inside pages and the premium paper is not acceptable. The pictures, taken with a Nikon D 80 and a Nikon D 90, print beautifully in the preview/review on my home printer, but are way darker in the book. There is no phone number, they take 24-48 hours to answer your email, and they are not responsive and won’t budge on their quality. I made a poor choice. I was SO disappointed that instead of ordering more books I RE MADE them back at MyPublisher and the quality difference is night and day. Blurb’s customer service is awful.

  18. Caroline
    July 31st, 2009 at 06:27 | #18

    I ordered 50 books from BLURB for an event. Did not have time to print the one book, unfortunately, but after making numerous books on MyPublisher.com I decided to try Blurb because I saved $5 per book. BIG MISTAKE. The quality of the photos is dark, they trimmed 1/4 inch off the inside pages and the premium paper is not acceptable. The pictures, taken with a Nikon D 80 and a Nikon D 90, print beautifully in the preview/review on my home printer, but are way darker in the book. There is no phone number, they take 24-48 hours to answer your email, and they are not responsive and won’t budge on their quality. I made a poor choice. I was SO disappointed that instead of ordering more books I RE MADE them back at MyPublisher and the quality difference is night and day. Blurb’s customer service is awful.

  19. August 3rd, 2009 at 16:25 | #19

    I have questions about what to scan my negatives at? I orignally scanned 35 mm images at 3200 DPI as TIFF files, and 120 mm images at 1200 DPI as TIFF, then converted them to Jpegs at highest quality, and reduced them to 300 DPI and resized them inches/pixels to fit the Lanscape or Large Lanscape books – Did I do this right? I also scanned slides as Jpegs, but at 600 DPI, or 1200 DPI – then made the reductions. What do you recommend in terms of scanning sizes? And then do I just need to reduce the image to 300 DPI and not change any inches or pixels sizes – those will change and adjust to the image layout designs I choose?
    They look good on the computer at the largest preview mode size, but I fear they will not look good on the printed page?

  20. August 6th, 2009 at 19:50 | #20

    I like the books. I’ve created and ordered a couple copies of one book. I’m looking for a book I can feel good about offereing in my wedding photography packages. So far it’s blurb. I love the ease of the program. But I wish the book opened up flat like people would like to see. If someone is paying a lot for a wedding photography book, they would want it to last a long time. I would like to see binding options I guess and even better or thicker paper quality.

  21. August 7th, 2009 at 02:23 | #21

    Достаточно интересная публикация, подписался на rss

  22. Peter
    August 11th, 2009 at 06:24 | #22

    I ordered my first book from Blurb last year, DISSAPOINTED. The colours were all wrong. After reading reviews on the web I still cant decide another company to try. I was looking at using creative memories. but you can only order a max of 120-130 pages? Same with mypublisher. Can someone please tell me a really good photo book company that produces top quality colour and a large number of pages 200-400+.
    I have seen a iphoto book and the quality looks good, but once again, you are only limited to 100 pages.

  23. August 12th, 2009 at 12:01 | #23

    So what resolution/type of images work best??

  24. August 14th, 2009 at 11:03 | #24

    Согласен с постом, но есть некоторые не точности=(

  25. September 21st, 2009 at 19:39 | #25

    Hi there!
    I would like to burn a theme at here. There is such a thing, called HYIP, or High Yield Investment Program. It reminds of ponzy-like structure, but in rare cases one may happen to meet a company that really pays up to 2% daily not on invested money, but from real profits.

    For several years , I make money with the help of these programs.
    I’m with no money problems now, but there are heights that must be conquered . I make 2G daily, and I started with funny 500 bucks.
    Right now, I’m very close at catching at last a guaranteed variant to make a sharp rise . Visit my web site to get additional info.

    http://www.theblogmoney.com

  26. Andrew
    September 29th, 2009 at 10:50 | #26

    I’ve seen the books from adoramapix.com (never bought one myself, just saw it when I was picking up my photos)…they looked to be really good quality.

  27. Tara
    October 20th, 2009 at 12:07 | #27

    My business partner and I recently published a book through Blurb for our photography and we have been dissatisfied with the majority of our book orders. The first (3-book) order looked good, with the exception of the book overall printing too dark. We decided that since everything else looked great, we’d go ahead and place a bigger order for the pre-orders we took from our models… when these were received they looked the same. From there we placed a bigger order to have books on hand for the book-signing party we’d planned. When these books were received they were not what we expected. The back page (our thank you page with details about the book), had pink wording (not the white that was designed) and the folding of the dust jacket was horribly off on a majority of them. In trying to have this problem fixed we contacted Blurb via email (as that is the ONLY way to contact them) and they promptly requested that we send the books back to them so they could do a reprint…. only problem with this is we would not have the books in hand for the book signing so that was NOT an option and we had to settle with giving attendees of the book signing, less than optimal books, rather than the books we and they expected. Blurb did try to reconcile the problem by giving us a $50 credit towards our next order, however this is sub-par considering one book cost us $37.00 to order and we order at least 14 ($50 to $518 doesn’t exactly add up to much). In our most recent order for one of the models that couldn’t make the book signing we are even more dissatisfied with the outcome of the book. The back page is not pink as before, however the front of the book is a bluish/black instead of black/white photo edit, and throughout the entire book all of the colors look horrible, thus reflecting on our quality of work. It’s ridiculous that this company cannot check their print quality before sending stuff out the door. I would not recommend this book company to anyone in the future; particularly if they do creative editing to their images as we do… this company is NOT consistent in what they do.

  28. October 22nd, 2009 at 19:44 | #28

    Knowing how your device hardware is wired does not necessarily tell you how its resources will be mapped because some chipsets change the mapping. ,

  29. Guaira
    October 28th, 2009 at 20:45 | #29

    I agree with the folks that express dissatisfaction with Blurb. I just created a book of one of my daughter’s collage stories, and ordered one copy: looked great. Got excited and ordered 10 copies: looked great too, and friends, family and co-workers all wanted one. When I ran out of the 10 copies, I ordered 10 more. YIKES! Should’ve read the comments on this page earlier and counted myself lucky to get 11 copies that were not messed up. These last 10 copies are terribly finished, with the hard cover improperly glued to the body of the book (the white paper that glues onto the hard cover–front and back–is full of bubles, as if my 4 year old had glued it). Contacted customer support and they were very nice, and agreed to send me a new set… and asked me to return the deffective ones to them! HUH?! What are they going to do with them? It makes me feel that, even though I sent them photos of the issue, they do not believe me. Also, it is the first time EVER that when ordering something that is custom-made, and having an issue, I am asked to return it to the seller/manufacturer. It is just a TERRIBLE policy. Makes the company look cheap and distrustful of its customers. Plus, even though they will–in theory–be sending me a UPS label to pay for the shipping, who is paying for my time to take the darn box of books to the UPS store?!
    That’s it for me, I will NEVER do business with Blurb again. I will start looking into the services listed in this page (thanks everyone who has listed one!)

  30. October 30th, 2009 at 01:38 | #30

    Извиняюсь за оффтоп, где вы этим летом отдыхали?

  31. Roger
    November 3rd, 2009 at 15:07 | #31

    Blurb’s software is horrible. Sooo buggy and crashes often. So often in fact that they updated it and adverstised on their main site that it crashes 50% less. Why would you even advertise that your software sucks 50% less now! Such a frustrating program. Simple tasks like copying and pasting a line of text can crash the program. Their solution is to auto save every minute (literally every minute) so as you’re working, the program will freeze as it autosaves. Imagine trying to highlight text in the middle of these autosaves and having to re-highlight over and over.

  32. November 5th, 2009 at 12:43 | #32

    I agree with Roger. Booksmart is an absolute nightmare. Select all doesn’t select all. You can’t seem to select text over more than one page. Font editing and resizing doesn’t work consistently. Very disappointed.

  33. rj
    November 5th, 2009 at 21:51 | #33

    I just got my first blurb photobook and I am NOT Impressed. I am actually disappointed that some of my images look darker in the book than on my monitor and the prints that I have from the photo lab that I use.

  34. Matt
    November 10th, 2009 at 00:10 | #34

    2 day express shipping turned out to be 10 day shipping. This was to be my wedding sign in book, but was not used because it was delivered 2 days AFTER the wedding! First and last time ordering from BLURB

  35. November 28th, 2009 at 13:46 | #35

    For any of you who are new to printing your photos, be aware that the image you see on your monitor will always be brighter than the printed photo — you must compensate for this when editing your photos, because monitors are so much brighter than paper. (If you know of any companies who make books like this, who do this compensation for you, along with color correction, lemme know…) Also, for those of you who have had color problems, have you color calibrated your monitor using a calibration device? That’s the only way you’re going to get the exact same color in your book that you’re seeing on your monitor. It’s too bad about the overall quality issues at Blurb, though. They are about the right price.

  36. Rives
    December 7th, 2009 at 10:36 | #36

    I just found out that they sent the wrong book to a customer I ordered for in early Nov. I’ve followed their protocol, which is, send them the issue via their “customer service”, no phone number is given and they don’t offer support by phone. They may get it right eventually, but now I’ve got to track down another half dozen or so to see if they got it right on those orders – -

  37. December 9th, 2009 at 18:56 | #37

    Thanks for all the great info. We just ordered 5 copies of our very first book. I have to say – it was stunning! We paid the extra for premium paper and the quality is excellent. We also chose the imagewrap hard cover and it makes for a handsome looking book that when we showed others they were shocked at the excellent quality. One caution for anyone deciding to use the imagewrap hardcover – make sure you read blurbs info about the layout because you need anything you don’t want to lose well away from the edges. Another recommendation for anyone choosing to do their first book – take the time to read through the blurb tutorials, faq’s and forums – time invested there will help assure a better outcome. Another caution for individuals who are doing their first book – remember your monitor images will appear brighter than on paper. I emailed one question to blurb when I was working and received a reply within a day. Delivery time was within the range they specified as well. We were pleased with the software, the information provided and the finished book.

  38. December 28th, 2009 at 20:08 | #38

    I’ve just put together a 120 page book on Blurb using my MacBook Pro, Booksmart, PhotoShop CS4 and the 10 mega pixel images from my Canon EOS 400D. Things are looking great on the preview screen, here’s hoping the £50 I am about to spend on getting it printed up will be worth it.

    Will let you guys know the results.

    Cheers

    Ben

  39. David Evans
    December 29th, 2009 at 18:48 | #39

    I just ordered a copy of my first book, it’s not a photo book, though and only has one image (the front cover) it was very cheap (£7.87 which is including the P+P) it is a book like the sort of book Patricia Cornwell writes (a crime novel/novella) so i’m not that worried about the picture… i’m just worried about the pages being trimmed to far, like some people have mentioned, so far i’m quiete pleased with blurb & booksmart… will leave another post when the book comes and i can have a look at the quality.
    David

  40. January 2nd, 2010 at 20:48 | #40

    Действительно вы очень интересно пишите, не зря мне друзья посоветовали, спасибо за посты!

  41. January 7th, 2010 at 07:43 | #41

    Какая-то у вас странная манера письма, но очень занимательная и легкочитающаяся)

  42. Kurt
    January 12th, 2010 at 16:49 | #42

    I read this post and then worked on my own blurb book. A word of warning: I spent approximately one week scanning, cleaning up, and laying out 80 pages of jpegs in BookSmart, then prepared to upload it to Blurb, only to find that the file format (grayscale) is “not currently supported” and “may not print correctly.” BookSmart, Blurb’s proprietary program, accepts grayscale images, even though they are not currently supported by Blurb.

  43. kid
    January 13th, 2010 at 19:44 | #43

    @Carl
    You can still get great prints at 300 bro

  44. January 17th, 2010 at 00:37 | #44

    Классный у вас диз, сами делали, или заказывали? Не подскажите где?

  45. January 19th, 2010 at 13:20 | #45

    I was really pleased with the quality of blurb. I suggest you use this for all your publishing requirments.

  46. January 21st, 2010 at 22:49 | #46

    Прикольно у вас диз сделан, это бесплатный шаблон или где-то делалил?

  47. January 22nd, 2010 at 23:07 | #47

    From now on I will be using this for all my publishing, I really like the quality.

  48. Molly
    February 8th, 2010 at 01:38 | #48

    I’m really disappointed with the book I ordered. The hardcover was dented in several spots and a corner was smashed in.
    The quality of the photos are bad. Printing the same pictures on a very low-end color printer gives no better results.
    Don’t waste your money on blurb.

Comment pages
1 2 3 111
  1. March 5th, 2007 at 18:46 | #1
  2. December 11th, 2007 at 11:17 | #2
  3. January 9th, 2008 at 10:16 | #3
  4. March 6th, 2008 at 03:28 | #4